The commandment is: “Thou shalt not steal.”
Most people believe that this commandment represents sound morality, even if they are not Christians. Nonetheless, it seems that this moral precept is forgotten once we start talking politics. And no wonder: Americans have been making up ‘right and wrong’ for themselves for quite a while. Obviously it was only a matter of time before it seeped into our national mindset.
A good example of this in action is the current attempt by the Democrats to extend the payroll tax cut, ‘paying for it’ by having the ‘rich’ pay their ‘fair share.’
That we are talking about theft becomes clearer when one considers exactly what the ‘payroll tax’ is. We are talking about the portion of one’s income that goes directly into Social Security. Your contributions, in turn, ensure that when you retire, you will be able to draw a steady check.
Now, the liberals tend to target the rich to fund a variety of their favorite programs, and many of those times there ostensibly is some ‘public’ benefit of them. For example, we might put public infrastructure, such as roads and bridges, in this category. Usually, though, the program favors smaller, special interest, populations. The appearance of a socialistic transfer of wealth from the rich to the poor becomes more profound the more targeted the program.
But the funding of the payroll tax cut by the rich really takes the cake. It is one of those few instances of a government service where the individual directly benefiting from the service is also the one funding it. Heck, it might be the only example of such a thing.
To have the rich pay for the payroll tax cut is to ask them to directly fund the retirements of the rest of the population, in a direct and transparent manner. The ‘99%’ are demanding that the ‘1%’ pay for a service that only the ‘99%’ will benefit from, without themselves contributing a dime. There is no ‘public’ benefit; the ‘special interest’ group just turns out to be exceptionally large.
This is stealing.
Stealing is wrong.
Therefore, this is wrong.
The real kick in the pants here is that while the ‘poor’ and ‘middle class’ are getting behind the highway robbery of their ‘richer’ countrymen, they are actually robbing their future selves. Since the amount of your contribution is correlated with how much you receive in your retirement account, by continuing to not pay the payroll tax, you are decreasing the amount you will ultimately receive. Continue reading