So you think illegal immigration is good for America?

 by Donald Hank

There is a rather common view among conservatives, particularly evangelicals, that if you give “immigrants” a better way of life they will be forever grateful and therefore become contributing citizens, helping us improve our way of life as well as their own. These naïve souls point, for example, to the family values and work ethic of Latinos. Facts like the statistic that 95% of murder warrants in LA are for illegal aliens, that more Americans are killed by illegal aliens (in car accidents or murders) than fighting in Iraq, or that 50% of the illegal drugs in some areas are from illegal aliens, do not seem to faze them. In fact, if you use the term “illegal immigrant,” they will most likely think of you as a bigot, if not call you one. To them, the concept of law and order as it has stood throughout American history so far, is anathema. Oddly, the vast majority of these have never lived in the battle zone we call the southern border region, where less Quixotic minds prevail and with good reason.

What they also ignore is that the majority of people of Latin descent who become US citizens eventually register as Democrats, even though they personally think abortion is an evil and gay marriage is absurd. They vote their stomachs, not their conscience.

The latest column at Mexidata reveals, in light of the Mexican Constitution, some reasons why Latinos in the US, with the notable exception of Miami Cuban refugees and their descendants (who have known the Left up close and more personally), tend to vote Democrat.

Quote:

“The Mexican Constitution stipulates similar rights [to our Constitution], but also guarantees that Mexicans have the right to a good job and decent housing.” [my emphasis, here and hereinafter]

Mexico is one of the poorest countries in the world, where many live huddled in cardboard shacks and are undernourished by our standards. A large percentage of them dream of coming here to live, to a nation that, ironically, does not guarantee these things. And their government encourages them to leave because it can’t make good on its promises. The sad thing about this situation is that once they get here, the first thing many of them want to do is create legislative conditions identical to the ones that failed back home. Where do they plan to escape to once their wish is granted?, one is tempted to ask.

Let me tell you about 2 people I have met who illustrate why it is not a good idea to import people from socialist states who form separate communities or feel little or no affinity for the US way of life and government. One was a German lady who taught English as a second language to my wife. She often said she was so happy to have left her country because now she can afford to buy a big house. But at the same time, she complains bitterly that our country does not furnish people with free things like health care and other benefits she thinks all human beings are entitled to. She votes, of course, Democrat, seeing no particular correlation between paternalistic government largesse and high taxes on the one hand, and one’s standard of living on the other.

Another was a lady who worked at the checkout counter of a book store near my home. When I heard her accent I asked her whether she was a local person (knowing she wasn’t). She said she was from Brazil. I read her mind and cultural bias instantly, picked up a magazine at the checkout counter with Hillary’s photo on the cover and slyly said “now there is a person who could solve our problems.” She smiled and agreed. When I asked her why she had immigrated to the US, she complained about how hard life is in Brazil, with its low median income, high crime, illegal drug use and other ills.  In other words, her complaints were all focused on phenomena that were in place there precisely because of the things that leftists invariably do in government.

So I said: “so you left because of the awful things your leftist regime is doing there and now you want us to install a similar leftist regime here so that you feel at home?”

She looked at me and just blinked. She really didn’t get it and she probably never will.

Quote:

“The Mexican Constitution recognizes freedom of religion, but puts more restrictions on churches and the clergy than does the U.S. Constitution.  Until recently, clergymen weren’t allowed to vote and they still cannot run for office.”

What? Mexico, the nation almost universally equated with corruption in government, has no clergy in public office and discourages religious people from participating in the political process? Now why do you suppose that would be?

Quote:

“Article 25 of the Mexican Constitution designates the Mexican government as the “rector” of national development. That means the government is responsible for the economy.  Article 26 stipulates that the government plan the economy.”

Let’s get this straight: The government that promises its people food and shelter, then reneges on its promise and tells them to emigrate to the US is admitting that the economy that has failed so miserably is the government’s responsibility? I don’t know whether to laugh or cry.

Ok, folks, now tomorrow you have a chance to choose between John McCain, who has openly advocated open borders and amnesty for illegal aliens (he won’t even use that term), and Mitt Romney, who, despite some obvious blemishes, as governor has committed no major infractions in terms of encouraging illegal immigration and has promised tighter immigration policies than at present (just not jailing patriotic border guards for doing their jobs would be a great start).

As absurd and incongruous as it sounds, thanks to their Constitution and the prevailing political view in their home country, the vast majority of Mexicans, especially the poor ones who come here, have been trained from little on up to think reflexively as socialists, even as they deplore the poverty, crime and corruption that surrounds them and stunts their personal progress, and so, sadly, once they or their children become citizens, the majority can be expected to vote as far left as they can, notwithstanding their family values and religious beliefs, which rarely seem to get in the way of bad decisions.

In the long run, the demographics of our nation will be a major factor in our survival. Our trade mark frontier rugged individualism is already highly diluted by our education system, media and politics. If we move just a bit further to the left, we can no longer hope to continue to be who we are.  Freedom will be gone forever.

God grant us wisdom to get it right this time. It is most likely our last chance.


You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

2 Responses to “So you think illegal immigration is good for America?”

  1. It is ridiculous how many people don’t want to secure our borders. Our current policies are endangering the wellbeing of the United States for generations to come. I think the first step is to eliminate the incentives of illegal immigrants to come. Unfortunately, some in Congress want to increase the incentive by providing subsidized college education to illegal immigrants. This will only encourage them to stay. I found a petition which is trying to stop this problem before it’s too late, and, as we get more signatures, money is donated to help the Border Patrol protect America.
    http://petitionearth.com/viewpetition.php?id=63
    We must stand strong at this crucial point in America’s history.

  2. From a friend:

    Hi Don,
    Some time ago I had the opportunity to talk a bit with a Mexican and his wife and two small children I bumped into casually at a restaurant. They were very well manered and nicely dressed. In the course of our conversation he started telling me that what the US of A needs to be concerned about is not so much the Mexicans from Mexico but the aliens who are migrating up from Central America, ie, Honduras Guatamala, El Salvador, Costa Rica, Belize, Panama and further down in South America from Columbia, and Venezuela, etc. He claimed it was not the Mexicans who were giving us problems, but these others who are coming from further down south. He told me that we should be more concerned with closing off the border below Mexico than trying to stop the Mexicans. whether there’s anything to this theory or not remains to be seen but I would think it should be looked into.
    I have been in the photography business for many years. I’ve taken many, many passport photos for Mexicans who are working for places like Strathmeyers Forests, and the many orchards up in the Adams Country area.
    I can honestly say that I have yet to run into one nasty, impolite, trouble maker amongst these people.
    A short story: One day when I was in my shop on Main St. in Dover I happened to look out the window and saw a group of Mexicans walking up Carlisle Rd. One of them came in and asked me if I could give them some water. Not knowing what to do and being somewhat apprenhensive, I refused him and he politely went on his (their) way. In a few moments I started thinking about this and it bothered me. I got a gallon jug and filled it with cold water, got in my van and drove partway up Carlisle Rd. and found them still walking. I waved for them to get in the van. There was about 5 of them, all guys that could have torn me to pieces, and that I never saw before in my life. They piled in the van with all their gear and thanked me for the jug of water as they passed it around amongst themselves and all the while thanking me. I took them all the way up to Strathmeyers where they had jobs waiting for them. They got out of the van, thanked me again and I drove back to my shop. I can honestly say that I was not one bit afraid of them nor did I fear for my life.
    Now, this may have been a special situation and unusual as compared to Southern Ca. and other places, but I must say, if the opportunity presented itself again, I would not hesitate to do the same thing.
    I’ve had a lot of contact with Mexicans and gotten to be friends with many. I even got to know the owner of a chain of Mexican Restaurants around the York, Harrisburg, Camp Hill, Mechanicsburg area and we have a great relationship.
    I’m sure there are millions who do not belong here in this country, and I agree, they need to go, and now!. But I will not treat the ones who are here legally with disrespect. I do not want to throw the baby out with the bath water or put them all in the same barrel together.
    On another note. If we can give aid to all these other countries in the world and prop them up, then why don’t we see about giving some kind of aid to Mexico to get their economy in order so those people would not need to filtrate up to this country and take American jobs??
    This Mexican told me that there is money in Mexico, but that it is controlled by the higher ups and the government.
    Ok, enough on this for now ….. just my observation.

    Hello XXX,
    I have made about the same observation. I too would have helped those guys and given them water.
    There are in fact Mexicans whom I would hide if I could so they wouldn’t get caught.
    I am a nice guy too. But when I was working illegally in England, Holland and Italy, I knew that I would get thrown out of these countries if I got caught. People there didn’t say “Don Hank is a nice guy so he should be able to break our immigration law and stay.”
    Their respect and enforcement of laws didn’t make me think these people were bigoted. I respected the fact that they had laws and knew that as a law breaker, I didn’t have the right to argue with them. Was I wrong? Remember that I was a very respectable guy and worked hard at my low-paying (less than $1/hr) industrial and sales jobs.
    Yet here we are in the USA, many years later, and suddenly even conservatives have caved in to the notion that immigration laws were made to be broken.
    The guy who deliberately ran over the border guard in CA last week was a Mexican. Most of the gangs in LA are Mexicans. My wife and I watch the news on Univision, the Spanish-language TV station in Miami, and almost every day we see stories of Mexicans who capture and kill little children there and hold them hostage for money or kill them to sell their organs. They think absolutely nothing of it.
    When we keep our borders open, we have the good, the bad and the absolutely hideous coming into our country.
    OUR children will pay for this, so it is not MY sovereignty or yours to give away.
    Let me know what you think about this.
    Best,
    Don

Leave a Reply